Objectivity as the Fruit of Authentic Subjectivity
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15633/pch.3754Keywords:
Objectivity of Human Knowing, Subjectivity and Objectivity, Critical Problem, Transcendental Method, Structure of Human Consciousness, Bernard LonerganAbstract
One of the most important problems of philosophy is the “critical problem”, the problem of bridge between the human mind and the world, the external reality. It is the question of relations between the subject and the object. The interesting solution for this problem is given by Bernard Lonergan SJ (1904–1984), one of the most important Catholic English-speaking thinkers of the twentieth century. It would be difficult to point to someone who influenced the American Catholic philosophy and theology from the inside out more than he did: that is why he is called the “American Rahner „. He tries to connect the great tradition of Thomism and Augustinianism and, on the other hand, classical and modern philosophy, German idealism and English Empiricism. At the heart of his thinking is the theory of the human mind. With the help of transcendental and phenomenological methods, Lonergan demonstrates that the mental structure of man consists of five levels: the empirical level, the intellectual level, the rational level, the responsible level and the level of religious experience, which together create a cumulative process that leads to knowledge and decision. The most important point here is he act of understanding, the insight, which always has a creative moment, especially on the second and third levels, as an effect of the subject’s work. The correct understanding of this moment enables a mediation between the empirical, rational and idealistic understanding of the knowledge process. Correct action on all levels, faithfulness to the nature of the subject, leads to truth – according to Lonergan’s very apt maxim: objectivity is the fruit of the authentic subjectivity.
References
Beards A., Method in Metaphysics. Lonergan and the Future of Analytical Philosophy, Toronto/Buffalo/London 2008.
Crowe F. E., Bernard Lonergan’s Thought on Ultimate Reality and Meaning, “Ultimate Reality and Meaning” 4 (1981), pp. 58–87.
Crowe F. E., Lonergan, London 1992.
Herbut J., Metoda transcendentalna: obiektywność poznania i jej kryterium. Omówienie koncepcji B. J. F. Lonergana, (The Transcendental Method: Objectivity of Cognition and Its Criterion. The Discussion of BJF Lonergan’s Conception), “RocznikiFilozoficzne” 28 (1980), pp. 91–117.
Lonergan B., An Interview with Fr. Bernard Lonergan, S. J., in: A Second Collection: Papers by Bernard J. F. Lonergan, S. J., (ed. W. F. Ryan, B. J. Tyrrell), Philadelphia 1974, p. 209–230.
Lonergan B., A Post-Hegelian Philosophy of Religion, in: A Third Collection: Papers by Bernard J. F. Lonergan, S. J., (ed. F. E. Crowe), London 1985, pp. 202–223.
Lonergan B., Insight. A Study of Human Understanding, London 1983.
Lonergan B., Metoda w teologii, trans. A. Bronk, Warszawa 1976.
Lonergan B., Openness and Religious Experience, in: Collection: Papers by Bernard J. F. Lonergan, S. J., (ed. F. E. Crowe, R. M. Doran), Toronto 1988, pp. 185–187.
Lonergan B., Philosophy of God, and Theology, Philadelphia 1973.
Lonergan B., Questionnaire on Philosophy, “Method: Journal of Lonergan Studies” 2 (1984), pp. 1–35.
Lonergan B., Religious Commitment, in: J. Papin (ed.), The Pilgrim People: A Vision with Hope, Villanova 1970, pp. 44–69.
Lonergan B., Second Lecture: Religious Knowledge, in: A Third Collection: Papers by Bernard J. F. Lonergan, S. J., (ed. F. E. Crowe), London 1985, pp. 129–145.
Lonergan B., The Subject, in: A Second Collection by Bernard Lonergan S.J., ed. W.F. Ryan, B.J. Tyrrell, Philadelphia 1974, pp. 69–86.
Lonergan B., Understanding and Being: An Introduction and Companion to Insight. The Halifax Lectures by Bernard Lonergan, ed. Elizabeth A. Morelli, M. D. Morelli, New York–Toronto 1980.
Lonergan B., Verbum: Word and Idea in Aquinas (ed. D. B. Burell, C. S. C.), Notre Dame 1967.
McCool G. A., The Philosophical Theology of Rahner and Lonergan, in: R. J. Roth (ed.), God Knowable and Unknowable, New York 1973, pp. 123–157.
Oko D., Łaska i wolność. Łaska w Biblii, nauczaniu Kościoła i teologii współczesnej, Kraków 1997. (Grace and Freedom. Grace in the Bible, the Teaching of the Church and Contemporary Theology).
Oko D., Metoda transcendentalna jako metoda metafizyki po zwrocie antropologicznym, (“The Transcendental Method as a Method of Metaphysics after an Anthropological Turn,”) „Analecta Cracoviensia” 28 (1996), pp. 234–253.
Oko D., The Transcendental Way to God according to Bernard Lonergan, Frankfurt am Main/Bern/New York/Paris 1991.
Oko. D., W poszukiwaniu pewności. Próba transcendentalnego ugruntowania metafizyki w filozofiach Emericha Coretha i Bernarda Lonergana, (In Search of Certainty. An Attempt at Transcendental Grounding of Metaphysics in the Philosophies of Emerich Coreth and Bernard Lonergan), Kraków 2010.
Popper K. R., Droga do wiedzy. Domysły i refutacje, trans. S. Amsterdamski, Warszawa 1999.
Popper K. R., Status poznawczy nauki i metafizyki, „Znak” 285 (1978), pp. 367–387.
Sala G. B., Die Introspektion als Schlüssel zur Erkenntnislehre des hl. Thomas von Aquin,,,Theologie und Philosophie” 49 (1974), pp. 477–482.
Sala G. B., Die Struktur der menschlichenErkenntnis. EineErkenntnislehre, Darmstadt 2009.
Sala G. B., Intentionality versus Intuition, w: G. B. Sala, Lonergan and Kant: Five Essays on Human Knowledge, ed. R. M. Doran, trans. J. Spoerl, Toronto/Buffalo/London 1994, pp. 80–101.
Sala G. B., Kant, Lonergan und der christliche Glaube. Ausgewählte philosophische Beiträge. Festgabezum 75. Geburtstag, (ed. U. L. Lehner and R. K. Tacelli), Nordhausen 2005.
Sala G. B., Lonergan and Kant: Five Essays on Human Knowledge, ed. R. M. Doran, trans. J. Spoerl, Toronto/Buffalo/London 1994.
Sala G., Seinserfahrung und Seinshorizontnach E. Coreth und B. Lonergan, ZKTh 89 (1967), pp. 294–338.
Shaughnessy W. G., The Subject in the Transcendental Method of Bernard Lonergan, in: Faculta Eclesiástica de Filosofía Universidad de Navarra, Excerpta e Dissertatonibus in Philosophia, Pamplona 1992, pp. 229–348.
Tilliette X., Chrystus filozofów. Prolegomena do chrystologii filozoficznej, trans. A. Ziernicki, Kraków 1996.
Vertin M., Philosophy of God, Theology, and the Problems of Evil, “Laval theologique et philosophique” 37 (1981), pp. 15–31.
Walczak W., Wgląd i poznanie. Epistemologia Bernarda J.F. Lonergana, Lublin 2012.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain the copyright and full publishing rights without restrictions, and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).