Doctor Crucis. The Criteria for Conferral of the Title of Doctor of the Church and their Application to the Case of Edith Stein. Part I
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15633/pch.13109Keywords:
Church Father, Doctor of the Church, eminent doctrine (eminens doctrina), Edith Stein, Doctor of the Cross (Doctor Crucis), John Paul IIAbstract
Edith Stein is widely recognised as a saint, a martyr, a victim of the Holocaust and a female philosopher – but can she be a Doctor of the Church? So far, thirty-seven figures, including four women, carry the title due to their so-called ‘eminent doctrines’, eminentes doctrinae. For centuries, a procedural difficulty existed in awarding the titles to martyrs, however, in the second decade of the 21st century, the Congregation for the Causes of Saints reached a conclusion that martyrdom is not, in principle, an obstacle in awarding
the title. A question, therefore, can be posed: does the legacy of someone among the Christian martyrs fulfill the criteria of the Church’s Doctorate?
The aim of this article is to investigate the criteria for conferral of the title of the Doctor of the Church, prime among which is a criterion called eminens doctrina, and apply them to one example, that of Edith Stein. In doing so, I consider the question purely historically and philosophically, starting out with definitions of the Father of the Church and the Doctor of the Church in part one (available below). In the second part of the article (available in 2024), I ask what aspects of the female martyr’s theology, philosophy and spirituality fulfill the criteria of an eminent doctrine, as formulated in the Church’s documents, and which are insufficient or lacking. In order to highlight the nature of a particular criterion, I contrast Stein’s case with other recently debated cases, such as those of Irenaeus of Lyons and John Paul II.
References
Amato A., Gregorio di Narek. Dottore della Chiesa, Vatican 2015, Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
Amato A., Santi e Beati. Come procede la Chiesa?, Vatican 2016, Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
Augustine of Hippo, O wolnej woli, in: idem, Dialogi filozoficzne. Tom III, trans. J. Modrzejewski, A. Trombala, Warsaw 1953, PAX.
Augustine of Hippo, Przeciw Julianowi, „Pisma Starochrześcijańskich Pisarzy”, trans. W. Eborowicz, t. 19, z. 2, Warsaw 1977, Akademia Teologii Katolickiej.
Baron A., Pietras H. (eds.), Dokumenty Soborow Powszechnych. Tom I. Tekst łaciński, grecki, polski, Cracow 2009, WAM.
Batholomeao of Lukka, Historia Ecclesiastica Nova, Florence 1317.
Benedict XIV, De servorum Dei beatificatione et beatorum canonizatione, vol. I–IV, Bologna, 1734–1738.
Benedict XVI, Church Fathers and Teachers: From Saint Leo the Great to Peter Lombard, trans. L’Osservatore Romano, San Francisco 2010, Ignatius Press.
Benedict XVI, Church Fathers: From Clement of Rome to Augustine, trans. L’Osservatore Romano, San Francisco 2009, Ignatius Press.
Betti U., A proposito del conferimento del titolo di Dottore della Chiesa, Antonianum 63 (1998), pp. 278–291.
Brylowski J., Translator’s Note, in: Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, trans. J. Brylowski, Pelplin 2018, Bernardinum, pp. 7–8.
Castellano Cervera J., Eminens doctrina. Un requisito necesario para ser doctor de la Iglesia, „Teresianum”, 46 (1995), pp. 3–21.
Congregatio de Causis Sanctorum, Le cause dei Santi, 2018, Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
Denzinger H., Echiridion symbolorum, P. Hunermann (ed.), Freiburg–Basel–Wien, 2009, Herder.
Drączkowski F., Patrologia, Pelplin–Lublin 1999, Bernardinum.
Drobner H.R., The Fathers of the Church. A Comprehensive Introduction, trans. S.S. Schatzmann; Massachusetts 2007, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 2007, Baker Publishing Group.
Eusebius of Caesarea, Historia ecclesiastica, Greek Original ed. H. Pietras, Polish trans. by A. Caba based on trans. by A. Lisiecki, Cracow 2013, WAM.
Fiedorowicz M., Teologia ojców Kościoła. Podstawy wczesnochrześcijańskiej refleksji nad wiarą, trans. W. Szymona, Cracow 2009, Mysterion.
Francis I, Epicoco L.M., San Giovanni Paolo Magno, Milan 2020, Edizioni San Paolo.
Gelasius I, Decretum Gelasianum in: H. Denzinger, Echiridion symbolorum, P. Hunermann (ed.), Freiburg–Basel–Wien 2009, Herder.
Gerl-Falkovitz H.-B., In which Way the Term ‘Truth’ Becomes Meaningful?, in: Dialog o człowieku w drodze do prawdy, Wroclaw 2020, Towarzystwo Edyty Stein, pp. 187–198.
Gerontikon, trans. M. Borkowska, Cracow 1983, Wydawnictwo Benedyktynów Tyniec.
Gogola J.W. (ed.), Światłość w ciemności, Cracow 2003, Wydawnictwo Karmelitów Bosych.
Green B., The Soteriology of Leo the Great, Oxford 2008, Oxford University Press.
Groń R., Fenomen „Doktora Kościoła” w historycznym rozwoju, „Wrocławski Przegląd Teologiczny” 7 (1999) 1, pp. 53–64.
Grzegorczyk A., Ponad kulturami. Uniwersalizm Edyty Stein, Poznań 2010, Wydawnictwo Poznańskie.
Guerrero van der Meijden J., Person and Dignity in Edith Stein’s Writings: Investigated in Comparison to the Writings of the Doctors of the Church and the Magisterial Documents of the Catholic Church, Boston–Berlin 2019, de Gruyter.
Guerrero van der Meijden J., Zagadnienie wczucia wg. Edyty Stein a symbol „Auschwitz”, „Pismo Towarzystwa Filozofii Religii” IV (2017), pp. 47–76.
Herbstrith W. (ed.), Never Forget: Christian and Jewish Perspectives on Edith Stein, “Carmelite Studies”, Washington 1998, ICS Publications.
von Hildebrand D., Trojan Horse in the City of God. Catholic Crisis Explained, Manchester, New Hampshire 1967, Sophia Institute Press.
International Theological Commision, Nadzieja zbawienia dla dzieci, które umierają bez chrztu, trans. J. Królikowski, Poznań 2008, Pallottinum, http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20070419_unbaptised-infants_pl.pdf (12.10.2020).
Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, trans. J. Brylowski, Pelplin 2018, Bernardinum.
John Paul II, Concelebrazione Eucaristica in Occasione dell’apertura della II assembla speciale per l’Europa del sinodo dei vescovi, 1 October 1999.
John Paul II, Fides et ratio, 1998.
John Paul II, Homilia wygłoszona podczas Mszy kanonizacyjnej błogosławionej księżnej krakowskiej Kingi [Homily on the canonization of St. Kinga, a Duchess of Cracow], Stary Sącz 10 July 1999.
John Paul II, Homily for the Canonization of Edith Stein, 11 October 1998.
John Paul II, Seligsprechung von Schwester Benedicta Teresia vom Kreuz, Stadion Koln–Mungersdorf, 1 May 1987.
Leo the Great, Sermons, trans. J. P. Freeland CSJB, A. J. Conway SSJ, Washington, D.C. Catholic University of America Press, 1996.
Longosz S., Ojcowie Kościoła. Semantyczny rozwój pojęcia, „Vox Patrum” 9 (16) 1989, pp. 61–108.
MacIntyre A., Edith Stein. Philosophical Prologue 1913‒1922, New York–Toronto–Plymouth 2007, Rowman & Littlefield.
Majkrzyk H., Doktor Doktorów. Święty Tomasz z Akwinu, Kęty 2012, Derewiecki.
Materiały z Sesji Naukowo Pastoralnej ‘Święta Edyta Stein Doktorem Kościoła?’, 22 March 2003, Kuria Krakowskiej Prowincji Karmelitow Bosych, Cracow 2003, Wydawnictwo Karmelitów Bosych.
Napiórkowski A., Warchoł P., Divine Mercy: Will St. Faustina and St. John Paul II become Doctors of the Church?, Middletown, USA 2021.
Paul VI, Proclemazione di Santa Teresa d’Avila Dottore della Chiesa, 27 September 1970.
Praśkiewicz Sz., Cuda przedłożone Stolicy Apostolskiej i kanonicznie zatwierdzone do gloryfikacji najnowszych Świętych i Błogosławionych Karmelu Terezjańskiego, https://www.karmel.pl/cud-do-kanonizacji-siostry-teresy-benedykty-od-krzyza/ (12.10.2020).
Praśkiewicz Sz., Kanonizacja s. Teresy Benedykty od Krzyża (Edyty Stein), https://opoka.org.pl/biblioteka/T/TH/THW/kanon.html (12.10.2020).
Rahner H., Kirchenlehrer, in: Lexikon fur Theologie und Kirche VI, Freiburg 1961, Herder, pp. 229–331.
Ratzinger J. (before papal election), Przemówienie w trakcie sesji zorganizowanej w 20-lecie pontyfikatu Jana Pawła II, 5 November 1998, Rome.
Stein E., Aus dem Leben einer judischen Familie und weitere autobiographische Beitrage, Freiburg–Basel–Wien 2007, Herder.
Stein E., Endliches und ewiges Sein. Versuch eines Aufstiegs zum Sinn des Seins, Freiburg‒Basel‒Wien 2006, Herder.
Stein E., Kreuzeswissenschaft. Studie uber Johannes vom Kreuz, Freiburg–Basel–Wien 2003, Herder.
Stein E., Selbstbildnis in Briefen II. Zweiter Teil 1933‒1942, Freiburg 2000.
Stein E., Spor o prawdę istnienia: listy Edith Stein do Romana Ingardena, trans. M. Klentak-Zabłocka, A. Wajs, Warsaw 1994, Wydawnictwo M.
Stein E., Zum Problem der Einfuhlung, Freiburg–Basel–Wien 2008, Herder.
Swan L., The Forgotten Desert Mothers, New Jersey 2001, Paulist Press.
Teresa Renata of the Holy Spirit, Siostra Teresa Benedykta od Krzyża. Filozof i karmelitanka, trans. M. Kaczmarkowski, Paris 1973, Editions du Dialogue.
The Venerable Bede, Epistola responsoria Venerabilis Bede ad Accam Episcopum, Patrologia Latina 92, J.-P. Migne (ed.), Paris 1962, pp. 303–308.
Ward B., The Venerable Bede, Harrisburg, 1990, Morehouse Publications.
Wessel S., Leo the Great and the Spiritual Rebuilding of a Universal Rome, Leiden‒Boston 2008, Brill.
Wiseman J.A., Historia duchowości chrześcijańskiej, trans. A. Wojtasik, Cracow 2009, WAM.
Wodrazka P.B., Eminente Dottrina. La procedura per il conferimento del titolo di Dottore della Chiesa, Verona 2019, Fede&Cultura.
Wojtyła K. (before papal election), Letter to Roman Ingarden on 22 September 1967 and Letter to Roman Ingarden 18 October 1967, Roman Ingarden Digital Archives, http://ingarden.archive.uj.edu.pl/archiwum/list-od-karola-wojtyly-z-22-09-1967 (22 September 1967) and http://ingarden.archive.uj.edu.pl/archiwum/list-od-karolawojtyly-z-18-10-1967, 18 October 1967 (12.10.2020).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The author declares that he or she has full copyright to the work, and such copyright it is not limited to the extent applicable to this declaration, that the article is an original work and that it does not infringe any third-party rights.
The author agrees to a free-of-charge, non-exclusive and non-restricted use of the work by Pontifical University of John Paul II in Krakow i.e.:
- to record and duplicate: make copies of the work by means of printing, reprography, magnetic or digital storage;
- to circulate the original or the copies of the work (disseminate, lend or lease the original or copies thereof, publicly display, screen or make the work publicly available so that everyone is able to access it at the time and in place they wish to do so);
- to include the work in a compilation;
- the Pontifical University of John Paul II in Krakow may grant sublicenses Creative Commons Acknowledgement of authorship-Non-commercial use-Without derivative work 3.0 Poland
The Pontifical University of John Paul II in Krakow makes the work available on the Journals Platform belonging to the University, according to the licence Creative Commons Acknowledgement of authorship-Non-commercial use-Without derivative work 3.0 Poland. Accordingly, the author authorises all interested parties to use the work on the following conditions:
- the author and the title of the work will be listed,
- the place of publication (name of the periodical and an Internet link to the originally published work),
- the work will be distributed in a non-commercial way,
- no derivative works will be created.
The UPJPII Press does not waive any of its copyrights to any target group.
