Peer review process
Peer Review Process
The journal respects the standards for journals published in Poland, given by the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education.
Reviewer - independent expert
Detailed rules for reviewing:
Stage I
The initial review is aimed at general qualification of the scientific article, in terms of its compatibility with the profile of the journal, compliance with editorial requirements applicable in the publishing house (in particular the style of footnotes) and general linguistic correctness. If the text meets the requirements of the initial review, it is referred to the proper review (stage II). The editors reserve the right to refuse to start the review process without giving reasons.
Stage II
The proper stage of the review, during which the text is subjected to double anonymous, for the reviewer and author of the text, review. The author of the text does not know the reviewers and the reviewers do not know the author of the text ("double-blind review process"). Reported texts should make it impossible to identify the author (text without the author's name and links allowing him to be recognized). The text should, in addition to linguistic correctness, be characterized by the originality of the subject taken, the justification for the thesis, and take into account the literature of the subject. Articles that do not add anything, or little new to the issue discussed, will not be accepted for publication. The review is prepared according to the review form and should contain a clear conclusion regarding the acceptance of the text for publication.
Reviewers in 2023:
Biesaga Tadeusz (UPJPII, Kraków), Bobko Aleksander (URz, Rzeszów), Borkowska-Nowak Małgorzata (KUL, Lublin), Czachorowski Marek (CI, Warszawa), Dominiak Łukasz (UMK, Toruń), Duchliński Piotr (UIK, Kraków), Ferdynus Marcin (KUL, Lublin), Grabińska Teresa (AWL, Wrocław), Guczalski Krzysztof (UJ, Kraków), Hołub Grzegorz (UPJPII, Kraków), Jarczewski Dominik (UJ, Kraków), Jastrzębski Marek (UPH, Siedlce), Kobylińska Zdzisława (UWM, Olsztyn), Kobyliński Andrzej (UKSW, Warszawa), Koszkało Martyna (UG, Gdańsk), Kraj Tomasz (UPJPII, Kraków), Krauze-Błachowicz Krystyna (UW, Warszawa), Kupczak Jarosław (UPJPII, Kraków), Lorenc Iwona (UW, Warszawa), Marczak Katarzyna, Mazur Piotr Stanisław (UIK, Kraków), Merecki Jarosław (PUL, Vatican), Mrówka Kazimierz (UKEN, Kraków) Murawska Monika (ASP, Warszawa), Nogal Agnieszka (UW, Warszawa), Nowak Witold (UR, Rzeszów), Pasterczyk Piotr (KUL, Lublin), Petryszak Karol (UPJPII, Kraków), Radziechowski Dariusz (IDMJP2, Kraków), Skrzypek-Faluszczak Jadwiga (URz, Rzeszów), Stefańczyk Andrzej (KUL, Lublin), Subczak Marcin (URz, Rzeszów), Ślęczek-Czakon Danuta (UŚ, Katowice), Toczko Rafał (UMK, Toruń)
Reviewers in 2021-2022:
Piotr Andryszczak (UPJPII, Kraków), Leszek Augustyn (UJ, Kraków), Tadeusz Biesaga (UPJPII, Kraków), Aleksander Bobko (UPJPII, Kraków), Jacek Breczko (UMB, Białystok), Juan Manuel Burgos (Universidad San Pablo CEU, Madrit, Espana), Sławomir Drelich (UMK, Toruń), Krzysztof Duda (UIK, Kraków), Tomasz Duma (KUL, Lublin), Sebastian Gałecki (UJD, Częstochowa), Witold Glinkowski (UŁ, Łodź), Robert Grzywacz (UIK, Kraków), John Hittinger (University of St. Thomas, Houston, USA), Miłosz Hołda (UPJPII, Kraków), Jarosław Horowski (UMK, Toruń), Hasnije Illazi (University of Prishtina, Kosovo), Adam Jonkisz (UIK, Kraków), Zdzisława Kobylińska (UWM, Olsztyn), Andrzej Kobyliński (UKSW, Warszawa), Roman Konik (UWr, Wrocław), Magdalena Kozak (UIK, Kraków), Marian Machinek (UWM, Olsztyn), Hanna Mamzer (UAM, Poznań), Maciej Manikowski (UWr, Wrocław), Mazur Piotr Stanisław (UIK, Kraków), Kazimierz Mrowka (UP, Kraków), Joanna Mysona Byrska (UPJPII, Kraków), Witold Nowak (UR, Rzeszow), Paweł Okołowski (UW, Warszawa), Artur Pacewicz (UWr, Wrocław), Dariusz Radziechowski (UIK, Kraków), Halina Rarot (POLUB, Lublin), Paweł Skrzydlewski (PWSZ, Chełm), Krzysztof Stachewicz (UAM, Poznań), Marek Szulakiewicz (UMK, Toruń), Antoni Szwed (UP, Kraków), Michael Dominic Taylor (Edith Stein Institute of Philosophy, Spain), Helen Watt (Anscombe Bioethics Centre, UK), Paulina Winiarska (UIK, Kraków), Władysław Zuziak (UPJPII, Kraków)
