Is appropriate to use the “anthropological” concept of race?

Authors

  • Mirosław Twardowski Uniwersytet Rzeszowski

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15633/tst.712

Keywords:

anthropological concept of race, racial paradigm, genetics

Abstract

The term “race” was introduced to the scientific vocabulary in the mid-eighteenth century by the French philosopher, scientist and mathematician Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon. In anthropology, this concept settled primarily through the German scientist Johann Friedrich Blumenbach. From the outset, the concept has aroused controversy among scholars. Even Charles Darwin himself expressed clear skepticism towards using the concept of race in reference to people. Clear doubts about the scientific basis of racial typology were reported in the early twentieth century by the American anthropologist Franz Boas, and later, in the 1940s, by the British-American anthropologist Ashley Montagu. In the 1960s, the American anthropologist and geneticist Frank Livingstone, on the basis of genetic evidence, sought to undermine the concept of human races. At the same time, a prominent American geneticist Theodosius Dobzhansky expressed a similar opinion, claiming that there were no races which would be “discrete units”. In the 1970s, the American geneticist Richard Lewontin, on the basis of his own research, proved that there is no possibility of isolating races based on genetic criteria.

In this article, we refer to the achievements of modern biology, especially genetics, to find out whether it is appropriate to use the “anthropological” concept of race. For a fuller picture of the issues of interest, we refer also to the historical sources, recalling the arguments put forward by various authors over the centuries against the concept of race in relation to human beings.

Author Biography

  • Mirosław Twardowski, Uniwersytet Rzeszowski

    Ks. Mirosław Twardowski – doktor filozofii, adiunkt w Zakładzie Polityki Regionalnej i Gospodarki Żywnościowej Wydziału Biologiczno-Rolniczego Uniwersytetu Rzeszowskiego, wykładowca filozofii przyrody w Wyższym Seminarium Duchownym w Rzeszowie.

References

Barbujani G., Magagni A., Minch E., Cavalli-Sforza L. L., An apportionment of human DNA diversity, „Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA” 94 (1997) no. 9, s. 4516–4519.

Biondi G., Rickards I. O., The scientific fallacy of the human biological concept of race, „Mankind Quarterly” 42 (2002) no. 4, s. 355–388.

Dobzhansky T., Comment on Livingstone, „Current Anthropology” 3 (1962) no. 3, s. 279–280.

Editorial, Census, race and science, „Nature Genetics” 24 (2000) no. 2, s. 97–98, http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/72884.

Editorial, Genes, drugs and race, „Nature Genetics” 29 (2001) no. 3, s. 239–240, http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ng1101-239.

Frisancho A. R., Human biological variation, w: Encyclopedia of race and racism, t. 2, ed. J. H. Moore, Farmington Hills 2008, s. 121–126.

Introduction, w: Encyclopedia of race and racism, t. 1, ed. J. H. Moore, Farmington Hills 2008, s. XI–XIV.

Jasicki B., Panek S., Sikora P., Stołyhwo E., Zarys antropologii, Warszawa 1962.

Jorde L. B. et al., The distribution of human genetic diversity: A comparison of mitochondrial, autosomal, and Y-chromosome data, „American Journal of Human Genetics” 66 (2000) no. 3, s. 979–988, http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/302825.

Lewontin R. C., The apportionment of human diversity, w: Evolutionary biology, t. 6, ed. T. Dobzhansky, M. Hecht, W. Steere, New York 1972, s. 381–398.

Livingstone F., On the non-existence of human races, „Current Anthropology” 3 (1962) no. 3, s. 279–281.

Long J. C., Scott N., Lewis C. M. Jr., Human genetics, w: Encyclopedia of race and racism, t. 2, ed. J. H. Moore, Farmington Hills 2008, s. 126–134.

Montagu A., Man’s most dangerous myth. The fallacy of race, Walnut Creek 1998.

Relethford J. H., Apportionment of global human genetic diversity based on craniometrics and skin color, „American Journal of Physical Anthropology” 118 (2002) no. 4, s. 393–398, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.10079.

Relethford J. H., Genetic variation among populations, w: Encyclopedia of race and racism, t. 2, ed. J. H. Moore, Farmington Hills 2008, s. 29–34.

Rosenberg N. A., Pritchard J. K., Weber J. L., Cann H. M., Kidd K. K., Zhivotovsky L. A., Feldman M. W., Genetic structure of human populations, „Science” 2002 vol. 298 no. 5602, s. 2381–2385, http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1078311.

Templeton A. R., Human races: A genetic and evolutionary perspective, „American Anthropologist” 100 (1998) no. 3, s. 632–650, http://dx.doi.org/10.1525/aa.1998.100.3.632.

Wilson E. O., Brown W. L. Jr., The subspecies concept and its taxonomic application, „Systematic Zoology” 2 (1953) no. 3, s. 97–111, http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2411818.

Downloads

Published

2014-09-01

Issue

Section

Artykuły

Similar Articles

1-10 of 28

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.